Should touch typing be like learning to drive?

The Stringer family of Melbourne's Sunburnt Suburbia say Australians should learn to touch type:

In Australia, more than 90% of adults have a driver's licence. To function effectively in the community you need one. As we attempt to become a knowledge-based economy, I think that the majority of Australians should also be able to touch type.

Maybe.

I learnt to touch type on a real typewriter as a trainee journalist long before I saw a computer keyboard.It's been useful for me.

Yet, I don't presume to tell people they should do the same.

There are alternatives.

If you don't like typing you can buy a tablet computer and use a pen. The first generation tablets were unimpressive, but I've seen recent models that do a great job of turning electronic script into text. Of course, pen computing is not for everyone. My handwriting isn't up to scratch – I suspect I'm not alone.

Another approach is voice recognition.

Like handwriting recognition, voice input has improved greatly in recent years and many people swear by it. The technology is particularly popular with disabled people and those who have developed repetitive strain injuries or similar ailments. Voice recognition companies claim 99 percent accuracy, in practice it takes some getting used to and patience.

As an aside, I first saw voice recognition demonstrated on a microcomputer (kids, ask your parents) in 1981. At the time a sales critter confided the technology was just two years away from mainstream adoption. It's been just two years away from the mainstream ever since.

The whole idea of touch typing being an essential future skill assumes tomorrow's computers will be like today's desktops and laptops.

I'm not suggesting these are about to disappear, but for many people iPhones, Blackberries and similar smart phones are replacing conventional computers. Perhaps texting, Blackberry thumb typing or even picking out words on the iPhone's virtual keyboard is the real key to being a future knowledge worker.

Touch typing is a valuable skill that will serve you for some time, but I'm not convinced that having more touch typists is the key to building a knowledge economy. Interesting idea though.